crashadams's game Reviews on Newgrounds

[GatherX]

I left the game running for a bit...let the workers gather etc. 9 hours...finally finished it and was sorely disappointed to find that there was no ending...just some text and the option to keep playing.

I would've liked at least another graphic like what was shown to you in the beginning. No real satisfaction for finishing the game.

Some basic critiques I suppose would be that the fish menu should've been on the right instead of the left as you spend most of your time in the ore menu so having to skip over every time you open the backpack made that memorable.

Other than that...the music and art and everything seemed fairly well done. I'm just very disappointed in the ending is all.

Coolboyman responds:

It absolutely should have had an ending. Your basic critiques make sense, thank you.

[Saciedy]

Wait...you can put content in a flash game that can only be seen via zooming in?!

Y2k4ever responds:

Its possible when you import a large picture and ,without breaking it apart, shrink it so the pixels will not be distorted, but they will appear that way when on the general screen.

[Break The Blocks!]

stencyldemo

I don't think it's appropriate to respond angrily to people critiquing your work, specially since you didn't actually create this.

XtremeExpress1 responds:

i did, i added more levels!

[Run And Gun]

Stencylworks demo game

I don't believe it's good practice to post demo games from development packages into the portal. (Stencyl . com) I've used this demo and even replaced all the art for it but I don't feel even my test with replacement art is good enough for the portal.

XtremeExpress1 responds:

i added more levels! SHUT UP STOP COMMENTING ON MY GAMES

[Merry Schmess Frenzy]

Argh sound

I noticed there were a handful of christmas/santa games on your page and this one is by far my favorite. I don't think the sounds were reused much, I like the animation/sound when santa get's hit, sort of a charlie brown aarrgh sound. Good one!

I like the background, very subtle and not overdone, the animations fit the art style etc. The only thing I see is there didn't seem to be much in variety, like something else to do etc. Overall was done well though!

good stuff!

whileworking responds:

Thanks for the review! It's a honor that most of you like the style of this game. Gotta add more extras to the next games tho :)

[Super Santa Kicker 2]

clones

I like it! well thought out like another has said, more explanation as to why santa is being cloned might be good but doesn't appear to be needed.

Good stuff!

whileworking responds:

Thank you very much! Hmmn yeah, of course it's a gameplay thing here, I don't think it has to be explained as well ;)

[3D Pixel Playground]

Awesome

I'm a game art student so anything 3D get's me all giddy. Not sure what sort of engine this is or what it can do but If this would allow 3d models in a flash game than I'm very very interested :D I use blender, maya, max, and zbrush.

JonathanEllins responds:

I did all the code from scratch - if you turn up the accuracy then it does more iterations from corner to corner, enjoy!

[7 Hours Til Sunrise]

weapon

was fun, till i bought a new weapon and it wouldn't shoot, didn't realize I had to buy ammo along with the weapon. good job from what I saw though.

Bandaro responds:

I've updated the game so that you start with some ammo for the guns now. Thanks for the feedback.

[TinyRPG]

familiar

Wow...you sir have done a great job here. Brings back memories of Ultima 1-5

This is the type of game I'd love to make if I weren't just a 3d modeler and couldn't code to save my life lol

keep it up!

LunaDrift responds:

if you want to do some art for the game... go for it. i'm thinking about making this open source.

ultima just rocks eh!

[Locked In Bathroom 2]

doesn't load

I'm having the same issue as the last poster, stops at 50% loaded. I'll come back and see if it gets fixed later though!

ValeriaCumplido responds:

Sorry, the server was down for almost an hour...
The game should now work correctly.
Thanks for playing!